17Capital’s survey on Liquidity in Private Equity Funds explores the views of more than 50 Limited Partners (LPs) and General Partners (GPs) in Europe and North America.
- Dissatisfaction with liquidity pace from mature funds
- Majority of LPs believe their liquidity needs are not met by the secondary market
- Majority of LPs currently use or would consider alternative liquidity options
- Fewer GPs offer liquidity service to their investors
LP-GP misalignment on liquidity pace from mature funds
Over two thirds of mature funds (2007-09 vintages) have not returned paid-in capital to investors, according to data from Preqin, a provider of intelligence on alternative assets.
LPs and GPs have strikingly different views on the pace of liquidity from their mature funds: 60% of LPs vs 21% of GPs express dissatisfaction.
“We have had an excellent ‘sellers’ market’ for the last 4-5 years and mature funds have not been able to return capital. Is this because GPs were too slow to deploy capital post-crisis or are they really bad at exiting? GPs should have distributed much more back to LPs.”
Jas Sidhu, West Midlands Pension Fund
Majority of LPs’ liquidity needs not met by the secondary market
More than 60% of LPs believe the secondary market does not meet their liquidity needs; 69% feel it is burdensome to sell on the market.
“A secondary sale requires long preparation and is not yet a safe bet when looking for liquidity.”
Alessandro Tappi, European Investment Fund
“The use of the secondary market is burdensome on LPs and is not sufficient as a sole means to provide liquidity. Alternative liquidity products are a beneficial development in the industry.”
UK Public Pension Fund
Majority of LPs would consider alternative liquidity options
Two thirds (67%) of LPs currently use or would consider using alternative liquidity options to a secondary sale, such as preferred equity or debt tranches.
“It is a matter of when, not if, liquidity options become market standard.”
Mid-market European GP
“[The findings] suggest that other tools to manage liquidity issues are required.”
Mid-market UK GP
“We see preferred equity providing a valuable role here, allowing accelerated cash-returns to LPs without the need for a secondary sale at a discount.”
Richard Clarke-Jervoise, Stonehage Fleming
Few GPs offer liquidity service to their investors
Only 1 in 5 GPs offer a liquidity service to their investors. The majority of GPs feel it is not a necessary service.
“GPs with a longer term perspective recognise that offering liquidity options will become a permanent feature of the market in future. Optimising investors’ liquidity, particularly in advance of a new fundraising, should become part of the GP’s toolbox.”
Mid-market European GP
17Capital is a leading global private equity specialist focused on financing successful investors in private equity. Having pioneered and brought its offering to the market a decade ago, 17Capital has provided €1.3bn of capital to-date to investors and fund managers across 40 investments.
With 25 professionals in London and New York, 17Capital continues to innovate and lead the market as the only dedicated provider of flexible financing with a global reach. The firm manages €2.0bn of assets raised from institutional investors across four successive funds.
17Capital’s offering includes:
- Liquidity services for investors and fund managers to accelerate distributions, enabling them to retain exposure to the portfolio and preserve upside
- Capital raises for investors and fund managers to make further investments and maximise their portfolio value creation
Fieldwork for the survey was undertaken for 17Capital by Equus Group, a specialist capital markets communications firm with a 13-year track record in private equity research and analysis.